Visa Lowers Swipe Fees in Europe But Stiffs US Merchants & Consumers

Billions of dollars are paid each year in swipe fees, and merchants accepting credit cards and paying the fees are not the only victims. We all cover the cost of credit card fees in the form of higher prices. There’s no competition in the U.S. swipe fees market, and all banks agree to charge the same amounts dictated by credit card companies. Nobody is stopping Visa or MasterCard from this price-fixing, which results in fees that are outrageously and unjustifiably high.

Now we learn that Visa Europe has proposed lowering swipe fees in Europe by 40% to 60%. This significant reduction would bring Visa’s fees down to only 0.3 percent of every purchase and would be very beneficial to European merchants and consumers.

So, why should U.S. merchants and consumers pay up to 4 percent of a purchase to swipe credit cards? What's different from U.S. purchases and Europe purchases?

Nothing.

Fees in U.S are eight times higher than existing European rates. Americans pay the highest fees in the world but while other countries took measures to limit the fees, in U.S. a credit card swipe fee reform is still desperately needed.

In the latest press release by the Merchants Payments Coalition, Dough Kantor, group’s counsel, says:

“European regulators are holding Visa’s feet to the fire for their outrageous swipe fees – even though the fees in Europe are a tiny fraction of what they are in the United States. There is no reason for rates to be as high as they are. This should be a wake-up call that credit card swipe fee reform is long overdue here.”

You can read the entire release here.

Credit Card Companies Make A Killing At Tax Time

You may be surprised to learn that if you paid your tax bill with your credit card this week, you paid a hefty, extra fee. The fee cost you anywhere from 2 to 4 percent of your total tax bill, and it didn't go to Uncle Sam either.

It went directly to banks and credit card companies. Bloomberg reports that if all U.S. residents paid their income and estate taxes by credit card, banks would rake in about $6 to 8 billion -- more than half of the IRS' proposed 2013 budget.

Granted, not all residents pay their tax bills this way, but more and more of us no longer use checks. 

Unlike Uncle Sam, merchants do not pass along the cost of what are known as "swipe fees" to their customers. They can't afford to; the marketplace is too competitive. Instead, some of that costs is deducted from their profits and calculated into consumer prices.

Banks and credit cards basically agree what the swipe fee will be or price fix, an activity that is usually against the law. As a result, swipe fees have tripled in the past decade and have become the second highest expense for merchants after labor. Meanwhile, in Europe, consumers and merchants pay swipe fees that are EIGHT times LOWER than what U.S. consumers and merchants pay.

Learn more about swipe fees here.

In Case There Was Any Doubt: Further Proof Debit Card Reform Increased Competition, Didn't Hurt Banks

In case there was any doubt about whether or not debit card reform was a good or bad thing for banks and the overall marketplace, Time.com banking writer Martha White weighed in today with this piece.

The big banks impacted by the Durbin Amendment, which cut debit card swipe fees by half, predicted doom and gloom not just for themselves but also for smaller banks and credit unions, exempted under the amendment.

It didn't happen. The Federal Reserve said it; the Kansas City Federal Reserve Bank said it; the GAO said it; and the FTC said it.

Instead of doom and gloom, banks -- even the big banks -- have been promoting debit cards stronger than ever, writes White.

"After an initial retrenchment, banks now are marketing debit cards as aggressively as ever. They’re even adding back debit card rewards programs, which many had discontinued in anticipation of the hit the regulations would deliver to their bottom lines."

Banks have been promoting debit as fast, convenient and secure and encouraging debit card use for big and small purchases- from a big plasma TV to a pack of gum. (Merchants suffer but banks make out big time on small purchases, charging 24 cents a debit swipe regardless of whether it's $1 or $100.)

"Besides looking for new customers, banks are trying to get current customers to use their debit cards more frequently. “Some banks are encouraging customers to use the card for small purchases,” Susan Wolfe says. After the swipe-fee rule kicked in, certain banks adopted the 24-cent cap as an effective floor as well as a ceiling. Since they earn the same amount if you buy a cup of coffee or a TV, they make out better if their customers use debit cards for lots of transactions, no matter how small."

Banks have even reintroduced rewards programs for debit cards in hopes of boosting fee revenue with increased volume of debit card transactions.

Read the entire article here.

How Credit Card Companies Make Money

Source: CreditScore.net

What Is Interchange?

source: visual.ly/fee fighters

States Need to Make Sure "Nobody Is Swiping Our Lunch"

Merchants refuse to pass constantly growing swipe fees onto customers paying with credit cards even though in most states they are allowed to do so. In today’s highly competitive retail market nobody can afford to push customers away.
 
In many places, like NJ, lawmakers have been very quick to introduce bills that would ban surcharging. In a recent article The Record columnist John Cichowski says such law would be a purely cosmetic fix to a problem that doesn’t exist. It might prevent sellers from adding an additional fee to credit card paying customers’ bills but it doesn’t stop credit card companies from charging merchants pre-set and unreasonably high fees that significantly reduce their profits and force them to raise prices for all customers. In the end, even customers paying with cash end up paying more.
 
To fix the swipe fee market, lawmakers need to look closer at the way those fees are set by Visa and MasterCard and force them and banks issuing the cards to compete for merchants’ business just like retailers compete for a customer.
 
“The people who pay these fees – either directly or indirectly — need lawmakers to dig deeper than cosmetic solutions to make sure nobody is swiping our lunch.” Cichowski says.
 
Read the rest of the article here.

Banks Mark Up Swipe Fees By 500%. Why? Because the Fed Won't Stop Them

In a recent report, the Federal Reserve found that it costs banks and credit card companies about 5 cents to process a debit card transaction. With all of our technological advances, that amount sounds reasonable, and debit card reform, as legislated in the Durbin Amendment, said banks should charge a "reasonable" fee for swiping their cards. Only problem is they don't charge 5 cents. They charge 24 cents, and the Fed is doing nothing about it.

It is a 500% markup! Unthinkable in any other marketplace.
 
The Durbin Amendment required the Federal Reserve to limit swipe-fees on debit cards that banks charge merchants and make sure the fees are relative to the actual cost of processing those transactions. New rules capped interchange fees charged by big banks at 24 cents, excluding institutions with less than $10 billion in assets. This reduction, however, remains grossly out of sync with the costs to swipe a card. The banks continue to profit unfairly from the swipe fee paid for by not just merchants but consumers in the form of higher prices.

Read the Merchants Payments Coalition’s press release on Federal Reserve’s newest report here.