Sounding a False Alarm: The Big Banks & Free Checking

Memo to banks: Do you have free checking or not?

Big banks have proclaimed rather loudly that they are being forced to do away with free checking allegedly because of lost revenue from debit card reform.  But guess what?  They did a survey and found plenty of free checking, and their own lobbyist, Nessa Feddis of the American Bankers Association, even said as much in a recent article:  “… most people still pay nothing for the great service banks provide across multiple convenient channels.”

A 2010 survey conducted by the ABA, for example, shows that 53% of respondents did not pay anything for their checking account. Three years later, the same survey found that 55% of bank depositors do not pay for checking, which suggests that free checking has actually increased during the post reform era.  

What’s more, additional studies released by moneyrates.com and bankrate.com show that the monthly service charges banks bill consumers are not even related to debit card swipe fees.  Take, for instance, the fees banks levy on customers for checking accounts.  Following debit reform in October 2011, these fees at the large banks went down and then rose slightly later.  Fees today are about the same as they were before reform, demonstrating that the ebb and flow of the fees does not correlate with swipe fee changes but rather shows the independent market dynamics of consumer checking fees.

Long before the Durbin Amendment was enacted, debit card swipe fees were skyrocketing.  In the last decade alone, they have tripled but there has been no corollary decrease in the fees banks impose on their customers.  And as banks would cry us a river about how the lower cap fees are hurting their bottom line, we only need to look at the numbers again to see that their argument doesn’t hold any water.  No bank that was impacted by the Durbin Amendment is currently facing anemic profit margins.  In fact, it’s quite the opposite. Wells Fargo and other banks have recently reported huge earnings.  And, MasterCard itself just posted a significant growth in profits during the second quarter, reporting that they are up 21% from a year ago.

The banks’ phony argument about free checking accounts is just another attempt to distract federal regulators and Congress from the real problem, which is their abuse of Main Street businesses and consumers in the debit and credit card marketplace.  Debit reform was needed and now we need credit swipe fee reform or else consumers and merchants will continue to be squeezed while the banks rein in sizeable profits at our expense.

In Case There Was Any Doubt: Further Proof Debit Card Reform Increased Competition, Didn't Hurt Banks

In case there was any doubt about whether or not debit card reform was a good or bad thing for banks and the overall marketplace, Time.com banking writer Martha White weighed in today with this piece.

The big banks impacted by the Durbin Amendment, which cut debit card swipe fees by half, predicted doom and gloom not just for themselves but also for smaller banks and credit unions, exempted under the amendment.

It didn't happen. The Federal Reserve said it; the Kansas City Federal Reserve Bank said it; the GAO said it; and the FTC said it.

Instead of doom and gloom, banks -- even the big banks -- have been promoting debit cards stronger than ever, writes White.

"After an initial retrenchment, banks now are marketing debit cards as aggressively as ever. They’re even adding back debit card rewards programs, which many had discontinued in anticipation of the hit the regulations would deliver to their bottom lines."

Banks have been promoting debit as fast, convenient and secure and encouraging debit card use for big and small purchases- from a big plasma TV to a pack of gum. (Merchants suffer but banks make out big time on small purchases, charging 24 cents a debit swipe regardless of whether it's $1 or $100.)

"Besides looking for new customers, banks are trying to get current customers to use their debit cards more frequently. “Some banks are encouraging customers to use the card for small purchases,” Susan Wolfe says. After the swipe-fee rule kicked in, certain banks adopted the 24-cent cap as an effective floor as well as a ceiling. Since they earn the same amount if you buy a cup of coffee or a TV, they make out better if their customers use debit cards for lots of transactions, no matter how small."

Banks have even reintroduced rewards programs for debit cards in hopes of boosting fee revenue with increased volume of debit card transactions.

Read the entire article here.

Banks Mark Up Swipe Fees By 500%. Why? Because the Fed Won't Stop Them

In a recent report, the Federal Reserve found that it costs banks and credit card companies about 5 cents to process a debit card transaction. With all of our technological advances, that amount sounds reasonable, and debit card reform, as legislated in the Durbin Amendment, said banks should charge a "reasonable" fee for swiping their cards. Only problem is they don't charge 5 cents. They charge 24 cents, and the Fed is doing nothing about it.

It is a 500% markup! Unthinkable in any other marketplace.
 
The Durbin Amendment required the Federal Reserve to limit swipe-fees on debit cards that banks charge merchants and make sure the fees are relative to the actual cost of processing those transactions. New rules capped interchange fees charged by big banks at 24 cents, excluding institutions with less than $10 billion in assets. This reduction, however, remains grossly out of sync with the costs to swipe a card. The banks continue to profit unfairly from the swipe fee paid for by not just merchants but consumers in the form of higher prices.

Read the Merchants Payments Coalition’s press release on Federal Reserve’s newest report here.

Banking Industry Wrong About Impact Of Durbin Amendment

Financial industry experts and three separate government agencies have confirmed that small banks and credit unions have benefitted from debit reform, putting to rest the banking lobby's negative and false claims about the impact of the Durbin Amendment.

Studies by the Federal Reserve, the Federal Reserve of Kansas City, the Federal Trade Commission and the Government Accountability Office have shown that fee revenues for banks exempted from the interchange fee limits have remained unaffected or have even grown thanks to the two-tier fee system mandated by debit reform for exempt and non-exempt banks.

As a result of the reform, small institutions can now compete with large banks and have attracted new customers with improved customer service and offerings.

For more information read the Merchants Payments Coalitions’ latest fact sheet: The Verdict Is In:  Small Banks Win With Debit Reform

Credit Union Survey Echos Other Reports: Durbin Amendment Works

In an interview with the Credit Union National Association, the Credit Union Times reported that credit union profits from debit cards have been largely unaffected by a reduction in the debit card swipe fee.

Just like recent reports by the FTC, the Federal Reserve and GAO, the CUNA survey shows that debit reform, as legislated by the Durbin Amendment, has benefited small banks, credit unions and consumers, disproving the big banks' false claims that reduced debit fees have harmed small banks and credit unions.

In a recent press release by the Merchants Payments Coalition, Lyle Beckwith, Sr. Vice President for Government Relations at NACS, talks about how big banks are misleading the public with false statements about the impact of debit card swipe fee reduction in order to avoid further reforms.

“The big banks have pushed the line that small banks are suffering as a way to stymie further reforms on rising swipe fees on credit cards, but the facts simply don't back them up,”

MPC’s full release can be found here.

Swipe Fees Drastically Slashing Supermarkets’ Thin Profits

Not many of us realize that when we quickly grab a $3 carton of milk from the neighborhood grocery store and pay with a debit card, the swipe fee that the store operator must pay the bank to process the transaction can be higher than the fee the store pays on $200 worth of groceries.

How can this be? Because the Federal Reserve is allowing banks to charge the maximum for a debit card transaction -- 22 cents -- under the Durbin Amendment, which reduced debit card fees from 42 cents a transaction.  The Durbin Amendment did not intend for banks to be able to charge 22 cents for a carton of milk or a cup of coffee, but that is the way the Fed is implementing the law.  A group of merchants have sued the Fed to make changes.

“These transaction costs have been eating into profit at an increasing rate,” says Bill Bishop, chairman of Willard Bishop, a consulting firm based in Barrington, Ill. “Retailers have been focused on trying to reduce them.”

Read more from Richard Turcsik, editor of Grocery Headquarters Magazine, here. 

BoA's Recent Move Proves Durbin Amendment A Success

The Durbin Amendment forced big banks to lower their swipe fees on debit cards and gave smaller banks a chance to compete with the financial giants. Bank of America’s recent cancellation of plans to charge for checking only proves debit reform is working.

Banks have been blaming the Durbin Amendment for everything wrong with the world, but as Doug Kantor, counsel to the Merchants Payments Coalition, wrote in a Huffington Post blog, debit reform has brought greater competition among banks to the marketplace.

 “The truth is, checking fees are set by competitive market dynamics, while swipe fees on debit cards haven't been. The fees were decided by Visa and MasterCard and every bank that belonged to one or the other charged the same thing - that looks just like price-fixing in every other part of the economy. The fact that swipe fees tripled over the past decade didn't prevent banks from increasing checking fees at the same time. Fluctuations in checking fees and other banking fees since debit reform are fundamentally the same as what was happening in the consumer banking market before the reforms were enacted with checking fees going up at the same or a lesser rate.”

In other words, debit reform forced big banks to compete for customers. The rest of Kantor's article can be found here.

Small Banks Benefitted, Not Harmed, By Durbin Amendment

Visa and MasterCard Under FTC Probe

In a recent report, the Federal Trade Commission has taken a close look into debit card transactions and found that small banks have not been hurt by the Durbin Amendment that lowered swipe fees charged by card companies and banks with assets above $10 billion. The report also announced that the FTC is investigating Visa and MasterCard for practices that might have prevented merchants from using lower cost processors of debit card transactions -- in violation of the Durbin Amendment.

From the report:

“…(I)nterchange fees paid to exempt issuers are higher than those paid to non-exempt issuers. A recent report by the General Accountability Office also concluded that ‘community banks and credit unions have not, on average, experienced a significant decline in their debit interchange fees…. This is consistent with early reports that the payment card networks had adopted a two-tier fee structure for exempt and non-exempt issuers.”

Doug Kantor, counsel to the Merchants Payments Coalition said:

“The FTC report confirms what merchants have been saying all along, that after the reforms small banks and credit union would not only not be harmed by debit but also would benefit from reform, along with consumers, merchants and the overall economy,”

For more information read Merchants Payments Coalition press release here and FTC report here.

Federal Reserve Overstepped Bounds By Catering To Banks & Ignoring Congress

In a Washington, DC federal courthouse this week, lawyers for merchants made a convincing argument that the Federal Reserve overstepped its bounds by catering to banks instead of doing what Congress instructed in legislation reforming debit card swipe fees.

Congress, they told the court, was clear about setting reasonable debit swipe fees and ensuring greater competition among card networks. It’s also clear that the Fed ignored Congress.

Fees charged to swipe both debit and credit cards for purchases total about $60 billion in revenues for banks and credit card companies, costing U.S. households hundreds of dollars a year. For merchants, swipe fees are the second highest cost for them, after labor. Swipe fees also have tripled since 2004, even while technology has lowered the cost of card transactions.

Part of the Dodd-Frank law included the Durbin Amendment, which sought to bring competition to debit card networks that process the transaction and to reduce the fees for using debit. The amendment instructed the Fed to set debit swipe fees that are “reasonable” and “proportional” to the banks’ costs. The Fed had determined the cost to be 5 cents a swipe.

After Durbin passed, the Fed dropped debit swipe fees from an average 42 cents a transaction (over 10 times actual cost) to 12 cents. The big banks, however, immediately leaned on the Fed, forcing their regulator to set the debit swipe fees at 21 cents, five times the banks’ actual cost, plus .05 percent of the transaction and an additional one cent for fraud prevention.

The banking lobbying convinced the Fed to cram the many costs of running a bank into an overinflated fee, rather than focusing on the banks’ cost of handling a debit transaction. The Fed also undercut Congress’ intent to make the debit card industry more competitive by not allowing merchants to choose among networks to process a sale.

As a result, consumers and merchants have not realized the savings they could have, and fees have actually increased for debit card purchases less than $15.

In too many instances, swipe fees eat up a merchants’ profit.

The Food Marketing Institute, National Association of Convenience Stores, National Restaurant Association and National Retail Federation filed the suit challenging the Federal Reserve’s rules. All of them are members of the Merchants Payments Coalition, a group of retailers and merchants who are concerned about the rising costs of swipe fees on both debit and credit cards. The MPC continues to push for credit card reform, in addition to correcting the implementation of the Durbin Amendment, which went into effect a year ago on October 1, 2011.

Visa and MasterCard together control 80% of the credit card market allowing them to dictate the amount of swipe fees that their member banks charge for each purchase. This kind of price-fixing is not allowed in other parts of the economy. The swipe fee rate varies card by card so a merchant never knows what the fee will be for any specific transaction. Visa has over 70 swipe fee categories while MasterCard has over 240. The fees also are 7 to 8 time higher than the standard European rate.

Follow us on Twitter at @reformswipefees and like us on Facebook.